Scroll down to watch the full video

She Was Hidden in the Garage. What Happened Before We Found Her Was Even Worse.

The first thing I heard was a voice coming from inside the garage. “Can I come down?” It was faint, frightened, almost too quiet to make sense of. We had already been warned that someone might be trapped inside. The caller had told us a woman was being held there, that her face looked badly injured, and that the man responsible was dangerous. But hearing that voice changed everything. Suddenly, this wasn't just a suspect barricaded inside a garage. There was a victim somewhere above us, waiting for someone to find her. We surrounded the property and announced ourselves. “William, this is the police department. This is your last chance. Come out now.” We warned him that if he refused, a canine would be sent inside. I could hear coughing. Then another sound. A woman. For a moment, nobody moved. We didn't know whether she was conscious, whether she could walk, or what condition she was in. All we knew was that she was in there with a man who already had a violent history, and every second we spent outside was another second she remained trapped with him.

The call had come from Christine Scott, who sounded like she was still trying to understand what she had discovered. Her husband had gone into their garage early that morning to get a dolly and encountered William Mazingo, someone the family knew. Christine told dispatch that William was a violent offender, that he had psychological and substance-abuse problems, and that there was a young woman with him. Her husband had reportedly seen the woman in the darkness and noticed that her face appeared badly beaten. There was another complication: William had previously lived there and knew the property well. He apparently knew about the cameras and knew that the side door was often left unlocked. Christine was worried about her elderly parents and her son, but she was also frightened of what William might do. By the time officers arrived, she was struggling to explain why she hadn't called sooner. She said she had only learned about the situation that morning. Whatever the reason for the delay, the important fact was now unmistakable: a woman was trapped somewhere inside that garage.

We tried the door. We knocked. We called Christine. Nothing. The silence became almost as unsettling as the information she'd given us. Then we heard movement inside. We announced ourselves again. “William, come out with your hands up.” We gave him chance after chance. Eventually the garage door began to open, and we saw him. He came out slowly, almost casually, as though this were an inconvenience instead of a police standoff. We ordered him to keep his hands visible and walk backward toward us. At one point, officers told him that his shoes and socks were still inside and that he could deal with those later. He was finally taken into custody. But even after William was secured, the scene wasn't over. There was still a woman somewhere inside. And when we asked him if anyone else was there, we weren't satisfied with the answers. We needed to find her ourselves.

We located Chloe Jones, a 23-year-old woman, inside the cramped garage attic. She looked frightened and badly injured. She had apparently been there for several days. When we brought her down, she was hesitant, almost as though stepping outside was dangerous. We kept telling her that William was already in custody. She didn't need to worry about him coming back. She had been trapped in that space for so long that freedom itself seemed unfamiliar. I remember the contrast: outside, there were police cars, flashing lights, people moving around, radios talking. Inside that attic, there had been almost nothing. Random belongings, a cramped space, and a young woman who had allegedly been forced to endure it for days. She was cold, so we offered her a place in the cruiser until medical personnel arrived. She had injuries to her face, and we knew she needed a hospital. But even before she told us what had happened, the physical evidence was already saying enough.

Later, the story began to come together. According to the account, Chloe had accepted a ride from William several days earlier. Instead of taking her home, he allegedly brought her to the garage and held her there against her will. Her injuries were extensive: a skull fracture, a broken arm, injuries to her fingers, and a brain bleed. She reportedly told investigators that she had been beaten with a baseball bat and with fists, threatened with a knife, choked, and at one point covered in gasoline while being threatened with being set on fire. She was allegedly told that she would never see her child again. And perhaps the most disturbing detail was the contradiction in William's behavior: between the alleged assaults, he reportedly acted affectionate toward her, even cuddling her. That detail is difficult to understand because cruelty doesn't always look like constant rage. Sometimes, according to victims' accounts, it can shift between violence and false tenderness, creating confusion and fear at the same time.

Then we learned who William was. This wasn't the first time his name had appeared in a police investigation. According to the source, he had previous convictions involving abduction, including cases in 2011 and 2014. In 2017, he was arrested after allegedly holding a woman against her will at a Walmart. His most recent conviction before this incident was even more disturbing. In 2019, he had reportedly kidnapped an ex-girlfriend and held her hostage for four days. During that ordeal, according to the account, he threatened her with a knife and attempted to strangle her. She eventually managed to contact police. Afterward, he allegedly attacked her again, leaving her unconscious on a road. He served prison time and was released on parole in April 2023. Just months later, officers were standing outside another garage, listening for a woman who was trapped inside.

There was another detail that stayed with me: William had apparently been released on parole only months before this incident. Christine said she had cut contact with him because of his behavior and drug use. Her husband explained that he had encountered William inside the garage earlier that morning. He said William acted as though he had simply come there because it was cold and raining. The husband reportedly heard a woman calling from the attic and eventually helped her down. His account raised questions about why police hadn't been called immediately, and investigators had to sort through conflicting timelines. But whatever happened during those hours, the important thing was that someone had finally made the call. By the time we arrived, the garage had become a crime scene, and the woman who had been hidden inside was finally being taken somewhere safe.

When we searched William after his arrest, we found a length of rope in his pocket. That discovery was disturbing enough, but the attic told an even larger story. There were signs of where Chloe had been kept, and officers realized how difficult it would have been for anyone trapped up there to escape on her own. One officer later said it was among the worst victim scenes he had encountered. Chloe had reportedly been unable to see properly because of her injuries, and she was terrified that William might still be nearby. We kept telling her that he was gone. He was in custody. She was going to the hospital. Those words probably sounded simple to us. To her, they meant something much bigger: for the first time in days, somebody else was finally in control of what happened next.

William was later arraigned on charges including kidnapping, felonious assault, abduction, and unlawful restraint, and he pleaded not guilty. The source reported that he was being held under differing bond conditions depending on the report. His eventual legal outcome isn't established by the transcript I was given, so the allegations remain allegations unless proven in court. But Chloe survived. And that is the part I keep returning to. The garage was supposed to be an ordinary place—a storage space, a place to keep tools, somewhere people walked through without thinking twice. Yet for four days, it had allegedly become a prison. The door was there, but freedom wasn't. And somewhere above us, a young woman was waiting for someone to hear her voice.

I still think about the moment she asked, “Can I come down?” Because that was the real turning point. William had spent days controlling where she could go, what she could see, and whether anyone knew she was there. But eventually, she spoke. Quietly. Just enough for someone outside to hear her. And when we did, everything changed. Sometimes rescue doesn't begin with a dramatic breakthrough. Sometimes it begins with a frightened voice asking if it's safe to come down. That is why I don't think the most important moment that morning was when William walked out of the garage. It was when Chloe finally walked out too. One person lost control that day. Another person got her life back. And sometimes, the difference between those two outcomes is as simple as someone finally listening when a victim whispers, “Can I come down?”